The Desk Is a Lie: Composing Poems Between the Interstate and the Checkout Line
Photo: JKT at Japanese Wikipedia, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons
The Myth of the Proper Room
Somewhere along the way, American poets absorbed a picture of how the work gets done: the quiet study, the window with a view of something meaningful, the block of uninterrupted hours. We inherit it from the photographs in the backs of poetry collections — the author at a desk that looks like it has never once held a permission slip or a car seat. I believed in that picture for most of my writing life, and it cost me years. I waited for the room the way you wait for a bus that stopped running at noon.
Then, over the course of about three years, I drafted an entire collection without the room. I wrote it on I-55 in afternoon gridlock, in the hard plastic chairs of a Jiffy Lube, in the produce aisle of a Kroger while deciding — I remember this distinctly — between two bags of Honeycrisps. The desk, it turns out, was never the instrument. The instrument was the habit I had been wrongly attaching to the desk.
Dictation on the Interstate
The first tool I owe an apology to is my phone's voice recorder. Mississippi traffic gave me the opportunity; the dictation app made it a practice. Every morning and evening, forty-five minutes each way, and I stopped treating that time as dead. I would open the recorder at a red light, wait for the green, and talk into the draft aloud — not while driving, mind you, but in the long crawls and the parking lots and the drive-thru lane where I was already idling.
Talking a poem aloud does something to the language that typing never quite does. You hear the false note. You hear where the sentence runs out of breath. A line you would have tolerated on the screen becomes intolerable in your own mouth, and so the commute draft tends to arrive leaner, more musical, than its desk-bound cousins. Some of the best lines in the collection were spoken at seventy feet per minute on a highway overpass and never substantially revised.
The Waiting Room as Studio
Here is what no one tells you about the DMV, the pharmacy counter, and the pediatrician's overflowing waiting room: they are rooms with a captive poet in them. The average American waits — by some estimates — a full year of life in lines and lobbies. I decided to file that year under work.
My kit is modest. A folded stack of index cards in the glove compartment. A pen that lives in my coat no matter the season. The notes app I have stopped apologizing for. At the Secretary of State's office, on a day my number was B-47 and the counter had reached B-31, I drafted a stanza on the back of a receipt for an emissions test. It was not romantic. It was not the room with the window. But the stanza did not know that. Stanzas have no idea where they were born, and they never tell.
The trick is a change of definition. For years I thought writing meant the session — the appointed hours, the ritual. What I do now is closer to collecting. The sessions were the superstition. The collecting is the craft.
Mental Revision at School Pickup
Composition, I learned, is only half the labor. The other half — the slower, stranger half — happens nowhere at all. I revise in my head during the idle at school pickup, that long line of minivans with their hazards blinking, everyone's engine running and going nowhere. I will take one line from the morning's dictation and turn it over like a stone for the full twenty minutes. Does it want the long vowel or the short? Does it want to end on the noun, or does the noun want to be a verb?
This is not wasted time. This is the oldest revision technology there is. Poets were recomposing lines while hauling water and minding livestock long before anyone had a study. The mind, given a line and a queue to stand in, will do remarkable work. What it needs from you is simply the handing over of the line — the decision, made once, that this material is worth carrying around.
Building a Portable Practice
For the writing students who ask me how to keep the work alive inside an ordinary, overscheduled American life, here is the whole system, such as it is:
- Claim the dead minutes. Name them out loud. The commute, the lobby, the pickup line. Once named, they belong to the poems.
- Lower the unit of work. A line is a legitimate day's labor. A stanza is a triumph. The collection is built the way a stone wall is built: one rock at a time, by a person with other things to do.
- Capture ruthlessly, judge later. The index card is for keeping, not for evaluating. Evaluation can happen at the desk, if you still want one.
- Talk your drafts. The ear is a stricter editor than the eye, and it is available in every drive-thru in America.
I still own a desk. I like it very much. But I no longer believe in it, and that has made all the difference. The poems do not live there. They live in the stolen margins, in the waiting, in the long blink between errands — and they have never once complained about the accommodations.