Ten Years Later, My Poems Have Been Living Without Me
Photo: Sgt. 1st Class Veshannah Lovelace, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
The Poem in the Anthology Is Not Mine Anymore
Last spring, a former student emailed to say she had taught one of my early poems — something I wrote in my late twenties, back when I lived in a third-floor walk-up in Ohio and considered a Tuesday productive if I finished a cup of coffee while it was still warm. She wanted to know what I had meant by the image of the frozen clothesline in the third stanza.
The honest answer: I no longer knew. I read the poem the way you might read a letter from an old roommate — recognizing the handwriting, half-remembering the person who wrote it, unable to account for their choices.
We tend to talk about publication as an arrival, a kind of notarization. The poem is finished; the poem is fixed; the poem now belongs to the record. But a decade of rereading has taught me that publication is closer to a departure. The poem leaves the house. It meets other people. It changes in ways you will hear about secondhand, if at all.
Disowning, Then Re-Owning
My relationship with my older poems moves in cycles. There are years when I flip past them in anthologies, embarrassed by their certainties — the young speaker who knew exactly how she felt about her grandmother, about the South, about grief. Then a season arrives when one of those poems ambushes me. A line I wrote at thirty-one turns out to be a better description of my forty-third year than anything I could write now.
The critic in me wants to call this growth. The poet in me suspects it is something stranger: the poems were never only about what I thought they were about. I aimed them at my life as it was; they landed in my life as it would become. Time has a way of revealing that a metaphor was also a prediction.
I have learned to stop apologizing for the early work and start listening to it. The woman who wrote those poems had access to feelings I have since built doors over. Rereading her is not nostalgia. It is reconnaissance.
What a Decade Rewrites
Here is what changes when you reread a poem ten years on:
The losses arrive. A poem about my father's hands was, when I wrote it, mostly about his hands. Now it is a poem about a man I have lost, and every verb in it seems to have known before I did.
The cleverness softens. Lines I once admired for their ingenuity now strike me as showing off, while the plain sentences I nearly cut — the ones I worried were too simple — have become the only ones I still trust.
The context evaporates. Readers never knew the argument that prompted the poem, the weather that week, the specific friend who hurt me. Freed of that baggage, the poem travels lighter than I ever could. It is, in this sense, a better version of my memory.
The audience writes back. Strangers have read my frozen clothesline as a poem about their mothers, their divorces, a winter in Michigan they never fully recovered from. They are not wrong. Once a poem is published, my intention is just one interpretation among many, and rarely the most interesting one.
The Rearview and the Road Ahead
I have started thinking of my older poems as a rearview mirror — objects in them are closer than they appear. They look like artifacts of a finished past, but they keep measuring the present. When I reread the clothesline poem now, I do not ask whether it holds up. I ask what it sees.
This, I suspect, is the quiet bargain of the writing life. We spend our apprenticeship trying to make poems we will not outgrow, and our maturity discovering that the good ones outgrew us on purpose. A poem that can still surprise its author a decade later has done the one thing we ask of art: it kept living after we let it go.
So to the student who asked what I meant: I meant something. I no longer know what. Read it however you need to. The poem can carry it. It has, after all, been carrying me.